|
May 2008
Recent Posts
Idol: "What we have witnessed is a knockout" Idol: Archuleta's first offering Categories
dallasnews.com
Entertainment Blogs |
Tuesday night will decide the winner of Dancing with the Stars' sixth season. But it may also settle the debate that has raged among fans from the beginning. Is DWTS a dance competition or a popularity contest? The best performer during Monday night's two dances -- a "Cha-Cha face-off" and the final freestyle -- was the celebrity who has been the best (by far) all season: Kristi Yamaguchi. Her cha-cha was wow-wow and she and partner Mark Ballas whirred, kicked, hipped and hopped through a high-energy freestyle. Simply put, neither Jason Taylor or Cristian de la Fuente could come even close to matching Kristi's style or precision. Of course, that's been the crux of another debate that's been waged among viewers this season -- is Kristi, the Olympic-champion ice skater hold an unfair advantage over her competitors with their dance-free resumes? After Monday night, it seems a moot point verging on sour grapes. Kristi was and is the best dancer, by far, and judging by the judges (who couldn't wait to start waving perfect 10s at Kristi), she deserves to win and become the first woman to win since the show's debut season. But if the show is a popularity contest, then the winner is likely to be -- who? Up until a couple weeks ago, the easy answer was Jason Taylor, the football star who has turned out to be a natural on the dance floor. But then Cristian hurt his arm and ever since he's been wincing with pain and grabbing his injured arm while insisting that he doesn't want any sympathy. He can't dance, but if that mattered he wouldn't be in the finals anyway. Jason is the best symbol of this show's professed premise -- to challenge a bunch of amateurs to find and unleash their inner dancers. But Kristi Yamaguchi is the best dancer. So which will it be? My one-word prediction: Kristi. |
|
Spotlight
|
|
Comments
Posted by Teresa @ 1:26 PM Wed, May 21, 2008
For once, the better dancer won. In the past seasons, except for the time Apolo Anton Ohno won, the better dancer did NOT win. Was Emmett Smith really better than Mario Lopez? Was Helio Castroneves really better than Mel B.? Was Drew Lachey really better than Stacy Keibler? Was Kelly Monaco really better than John O'Hurley? The outcomes show more of a popularity contest than real dance talent.